For this version of Mannie’s Fireplace Feast assessment, I used to be in pursuit of some great-tasting BBQ in Southern Illinois. I traveled a number of miles down the highway, and all indicators led me to seventeenth Road BBQ in Murphysboro.
The restaurant is situated at 32 N. seventeenth St. and it has each dine-in and takeout choices. seventeenth Road BBQ has developed a status as one of many area’s premiere BBQ locations. So with out additional ado, let’s see how a lot fireplace the restaurant might carry for this assessment.
Meals Taste: 2.5
Earlier than I stepped into the restaurant, I knew I needed some good brisket. I ordered half a pound of it. The menu describes it as licensed sliced Angus beef that’s dusted with seasoning.
I ordered brisket-flavored inexperienced beans, macaroni and cheese, and a candy potato with butter and brown sugar for the edges.
The restaurant additionally has home made barbecue sauces which are accessible at each desk. These sauces are Excessive on the Hog, Authentic, A Little Kick and 17 St. Pink. The 17 St. Pink is a Kansas Metropolis-style bbq sauce, whereas the unique is gentle, and A Little Kick has reasonable spice. The Excessive on the Hog is a French dressing dressing sauce. In fact, I needed to attempt all the sauces with my meal.
The brisket was pretty seasoned and had a very good smoke style to it. Nevertheless, it was additionally very dry. I attempted all of the BBQ sauces to see if they might assist coat the dry meat. The one sauce that was pleasurable was the unique bbq sauce. The remaining sauces had a robust vinegar style, which overpowered the pallet.
The edges all tasted nice. The candy potato’s cinnamon butter unfold is out of this world, which provides you a candy potato pie style. The inexperienced beans had a superb brisket-smoke style to them. Lastly, the macaroni and cheese was made, merely put, to perfection.
I’m giving the meals taste two and a half flames. The edges alone carry the rating as a result of the brisket didn’t hit the mark.
Meals Texture: 2.5
The brisket was not robust, but it surely additionally wasn’t tender. I really like a very good brisket to be juicy and have fatty items. Neither of which was true of this brisket. Its texture is carefully linked to dry Thanksgiving turkey meat.
The edges, nevertheless, had been all digested fairly flippantly and tasted good. The meals texture would additionally should get two and a half flames.
Meals Presentation: 5
The restaurant follows a easy however environment friendly plateware mannequin. As a substitute of conventional plates, tin trays lined with butcher paper home the meat. The edges are then positioned inside carnival-style paper meals trays.
The silverware is solely wrapped up in a paper serviette. I’m giving the meals presentation a complete of 5 flames. Generally much less is extra, and the restaurant follows the trade commonplace of tin trays.
Buyer Service: 5
I arrived on a fairly sluggish Wednesday night, during which there was just one different celebration there eating. As quickly as I entered the door, the waiter eagerly greeted me.
The waiter walked me to the desk and defined the menu and sauces on the desk. It took lower than 10 minutes for the meals to reach as soon as I positioned my order. The waiter additionally checked on me a number of instances to make small discuss and make sure the meals was to my liking.
It might’ve been straightforward for the waiter to do the naked minimal on a sluggish evening, however he went above and past. For that, I’m giving the restaurant a complete of 5 flames.
seventeenth Road BBQ is an a la carte restaurant, which suggests all its meals gadgets are bought individually. The edges had been every roughly $4 a bit. The half-a-pound brisket was roughly $17. The overall for the whole lot was round $37.
If the restaurant applied lunch or dinner specials, the worth of the meals would enhance. Nevertheless, the meals costs are overpriced. I’m giving the meals worth/value a complete of two flames.
Up subsequent is the restaurant’s cleanliness. I did my standard eyeball scan of the restaurant and noticed some nice issues.
There was a hand sanitizer dispenser close to the entrance entrance. The bar was clear, and the venue had a contemporary scent. The silverware was additionally fairly clear. I’m giving the cleanliness criterion 5 flames.
I arrived at seventeenth Road BBQ on a Wednesday night round 7:30 p.m. and dined with a buddy. The restaurant does have a non-public parking zone, however on this evening, it was not accessible in preparation for a cook-off competitors later that weekend.
I drove just a few blocks down and parked on a residential avenue. The stroll wasn’t too unhealthy on a wonderful evening. I’m giving the comfort a complete of three and a half flames. Beneath regular circumstances, I might’ve been in a position to park within the lot, so I cannot be unfair. However the parking zone is a bit undersized.
Total Rating: 3.5
The general rating seventeenth Road BBQ will obtain is three and a half flames. They’ve wonderful customer support and a beautiful venue however should enhance the meals texture of their meat.
Workers reporter Mannie Henderson will be reached at [email protected]